Civil War Monuments in the American (U.S.) South

Symbols develop meaning through social use, conversation, and definition.  The symbols in the South commemorating the Civil War, regardless of the original intent (which was very racist), stand as symbols for memorilizing those who enslaved and profited from the labor of black Americans in the nineteenth century.  These symbols have been used, and maybe misappropriated, by racists throughout the nation.  Black Americans were never part of the conversations surrounding the meaning and creation of these icons.  Regardless of what these icons were, they are now symbols of slavery, symbols that represent oppression (and America (U.S.) is full of these symbols).  If we want to keep these memorials, maybe we should surround them with images of the those who were incarcerated for nothing more than the color of their skin. Maybe we should commemorate the largest slave revolt in America that happened just outside New Orleans.  But, of course, this will cause ‘tension.’  This ‘tension’ has not been settled, but we are beginning to see conversations over the contemporary meaning of the symbols rise to the surface.  What matters now, is who dominates these conversations… the media?

Below is an article written by a professor at the University of New Orleans and a PhD. candidate.  I appreciate their argument, but I disagree.



One thought on “Civil War Monuments in the American (U.S.) South

  1. Most of my disagreement concerns the ambiguous idea of conversations and the idea that these icons can be used or interpreted differently en masse to remind the public of the horrors of the slavery. Social relations and cultural virtues and norms carve out spaces for meaning, but the production of meaning can be the result of many contingent, contextual, and unforeseen influences. I don’t know that the icons can be reinterpreted to remind the public of horrors of slavery.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s